Field notes · Coins · 20 November 2026
A suspect slab passed eBay's coin check. NGC's own photographs did not match it.
A 1914 Chinese silver dollar in an NGC-style holder reached a US buyer in October 2026 with an eBay authentication label. NGC's photographs of the certified coin showed a different coin and holder. eBay refunded the buyer, the buyer reported.
By BSJ Ventures on the Brich House platform
In brief
CoinWeek published on 14 November 2026 a counterfeit researcher's account of two eBay listings. Both offered a 1914 Yuan Shikai silver dollar in an NGC-style holder graded AU58. The first, from a seller outside the US, carried a certification number that is real. NGC's record for that number showed a different coin in a different holder, under a "Possible Counterfeit Holder" alert. The second listing, on the US site, was dated 14 October 2026 at $750 or best offer. The coin arrived with an eBay Authenticity Guarantee label, and its QR code showed a check dated 19 October 2026. The buyer's photographs differed from NGC's in the label, the insert, the prongs and the coin. The buyer reported that eBay removed the listing and refunded the purchase. CoinWeek notes it had no statement from eBay or PCGS, so it cannot say which step failed. The researcher's five other test buys of suspect coins were all caught.
The case turns on what each check looks at. eBay's coin page says PCGS authenticators inspect a graded coin's holder and label for tampering and against the listing, with no regrading. NGC says the alert means it has seen a counterfeit or tampered holder using that number. It has photographed virtually every coin it graded outside bulk submissions since October 2008. Its guarantee does not cover a coin in a counterfeit holder. So a real number proves only that a coin once received it. The record that holds is the grader's image, set against the coin in hand. CoinWeek's closing line puts it this way: "confidence begins with the coin itself, not the sticker on its holder." On the economy, the US personal saving rate was 3.8 percent in September 2026, against 4.5 percent in July, BEA data released on 29 October show. That is a thinner cushion behind a $500 coin bought on a screen.
What it turns on
- The number was real. In the first listing the cert number existed at NGC. Its record showed another coin, in another holder, with a counterfeit-holder alert.
- The label sat on the plastic. eBay's check on a graded coin covers the holder and label, and whether the item matches its listing. It does not regrade the coin.
- The photograph is the record. NGC has imaged nearly every coin it graded since October 2008, outside bulk lots. That image, not the number alone, ties a coin to its slab.
What we do about it
- 01Pull the grader's image. For every slab, the cert lookup page with its photographs, saved with the date and time of the check.
- 02Match four details. Label type and spacing, insert, prongs and hologram, then the coin's own marks, each set beside the grader's image.
- 03Record any alert. Any warning on the cert record, such as a counterfeit-holder note, with a screenshot and the date first seen.
- 04Keep the label separate. A marketplace authentication label as its own entry: who checked, on what date, and what that check covers.
Check it yourself
Tell us what you need held, or proven. Write to hello@brich.house