Field notes · Coins · 13 November 2026
A lower-graded nickel outsold the next lot. It carried a second opinion.
On 26 October 2026 a 1925-D Buffalo nickel graded AU58 brought $884.40 at Stack's Bowers. The next lot, graded MS62, brought $610. The first carried a CAC sticker, a second firm's view of the grade, with its own lookup.
By BSJ Ventures on the Brich House platform
In brief
CoinWeek published on 10 November 2026 a review of twelve October auction results. In each, a coin with a Certified Acceptance Corporation (CAC) sticker, or a grade from CAC Grading, brought more than chosen comparison coins without one. Two pairs ran as consecutive lots. On 26 October Stack's Bowers sold a 1925-D Buffalo nickel graded PCGS AU58 with a CAC sticker for $884.40. The next lot, a PCGS MS62 without one, made $610. On 12 October Heritage sold an 1857-O half dime graded PCGS AU50 with a sticker for $414.80. The next lot, an NGC AU53 without one, made $207.40. In both pairs the lower number on the label brought the higher price. CoinWeek adds its own caution: such pairs cannot isolate what the sticker added, because strike, surfaces and sale dates differ. Its summary is that "the number on the holder does not tell the entire story."
The sticker is a second firm's opinion laid over the first. CAC's own pages say its stickering service reviews coins already graded by PCGS or NGC, and that those two companies do not endorse it. Green means the coin met CAC's standard for the grade on the label. Gold means it exceeded that standard. Fewer than half the coins sent in receive the green sticker, CAC says. The sticker sits on the holder, not on the coin. A coin moved to a new holder can be stickered again only if it keeps the same certification number. CAC runs a cert lookup, updated daily, and asks a buyer to compare the number, description, grade and holder details with the coin in hand. So a stickered coin carries two records, one at the grader and one at CAC, and each is checked in its own place. On the economy, the 10-year Treasury yield was 5.10 percent on 12 November 2026, against 4.88 percent on 9 November, US Treasury data show. A coin pays no interest, so that yield measures what a holder gives up to keep it.
What it turns on
- The lower grade brought more. In two consecutive-lot pairs, a stickered AU58 nickel made about 45 percent more than an MS62, and a stickered AU50 half dime made twice the price of an AU53.
- Fewer than half pass. CAC says under half of the coins submitted for a sticker receive the green one. Its listed fee starts at $26 for a coin valued up to $3,000.
- The opinion follows the cert number. The sticker sits on the plastic. After a change of holder, CAC stickers the coin again only when the certification number is the same.
What we do about it
- 01Check two lookups. The cert number on the grader's own lookup and on CAC's lookup, each with the date and time of the check.
- 02Photograph the holder. Front and back of the slab, with the label, the sticker and its colour legible in one frame.
- 03Date the comparison. For any price set beside another: the sale date, the auction house, the lot number, the grader, and whether each coin carried a sticker.
- 04Log each reholder. Any change of holder, the cert number before and after, and whether the sticker was issued again.
Check it yourself
Tell us what you need held, or proven. Write to hello@brich.house